Skip to content

Search

Product type

All
Accessory
Action & Toy Figures
Apron
Cape
Collectibles
Costume
Decoration
Dog Apparel
Hosiery
Inflatable
Jewelry
Makeup
Mask
Poncho
Wig

Menu

Home
Products
About
Contact Us

Send Us An Email

Accessory Sale!

15% Off All Accessories with Purchase of Single Costume (*Pet Costumes Not Included). Discount Applied at Checkout Automatically!

Home
Stuffed Animals and Plush

Stuffed Animals and Plush

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

View as List Grid

FiltersFilter & Sort

Applied Filters

Clear all

Sort by

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Price

From $

-

To $

From To

Clear

Sold out
TY
Squidward Beanie Baby 8"

$39.99

View details
Sold out
TY
Pinky Poo Pinky Keychain Beanie Baby 2005

$12.00

View details
Sold out

TY
Castles Pluffie

$45.00

View details
TY
SpongeBob Beanie Baby 8"

$19.99

View details
TY
Piggy Pluffie
Very low stock (1 unit)

$70.00

View details
TY
Tumba the Gorilla Beanie Baby 2007
Very low stock (1 unit)

$30.00

View details
Squishable
Mini Squishable Reaper
Very low stock (1 unit)

$34.99

View details
TY
Milkers Pluffie
Very low stock (1 unit)

$70.00

View details
TY
Happy Birthday Beanie Baby 2006

$25.00

View details
TY
Shocks Beanie Baby 2006

$30.00

View details
TY
Docks Dolphin Beanie Baby 2006
Low stock (2 units)

$17.00

View details
TY
Sunrise Turtle Beanie Baby 2006

$35.00

View details
TY
Garcia Beanie Baby 1993

$30.00

View details
TY
Fortress the Unicorn Beanie Baby

$25.00

View details
TY
USA Beanie Baby

$9.99

View details
New arrival

TY
Paradise Pinkys 12" Plush
Very low stock (1 unit)

$85.00

View details

Previous
Page 1 / 3
1
2
3
Next

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Subtotal:$0.00 USD

Loading...

Free Shipping Available on All Orders, No Minimum!

Talk about your store

We are a proudly Family owned and operated small business out of Franklin, Massachusetts since 2016.

We know from experience how confusing and frustrating costume shopping can be. Whether its beating the crowds, or taking 2 weeks to get an online order from the larger Costume E-tailers.

We are here to make sure you have an amazing experience

We sell ONLY items that are stocked in our warehouse. Everything we sell leaves our warehouse within 2 business days. And our prices rival those of even the largest costume retailers!

So give us a try, and let us show you how simple and worry free this can be!

- Stephanie

Owner The Costume Kitty

Support and FAQ

About Us
Purr-fect Fit Guarantee
Shipping Information
Return Policy
Exchange Policy
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Refund policy

Payment methods accepted

© 2025 The Costume Kitty. Powered by Shopify

Choose options

Item added to your cart.

View cart